logo

Global Warming Reports

SearchRSS Feed

failinggradescover.gif

Failing Grades: How The Senate Energy Bill Fails To Secure A New Energy Future

2002-03-28

Failing_Grades.pdf Failing_Grades.pdf

News Release

Executive Summary

As the new home of Illinois PIRG's environmental work, Environment Illinois can be contacted with any questions regarding this report.

The Senate energy bill began, under Senator Daschle's leadership, as a promising vehicle for meeting our nation's energy needs, cutting oil dependence, diversifying our energy portfolio, saving consumers money and otherwise forging a path to a clean energy future. It contained important provisions to boost fuel economy standards, address global warming, improve energy efficiency and increase the use of renewable energy sources. But as it stands today, the bill has been weakened by a series of amendments supported by industries that stand in the way of technology and progress. Several Senators and their industry allies are crafting additional amendments to make the bill even worse. In its current form, the Senate energy bill fails to reduce our dependence on imported oil, fails to significantly increase our nation's overall energy security, fails to protect electricity consumers, and fails to safeguard our environment.

At a minimum, comprehensive energy legislation should adhere to the following core principles:

  • Reduce consumption of oil by at least one million barrels a day by 2013;
  • Protect the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, roadless areas in our public lands, and other wild places from oil and gas development;
  • Guarantee that at least 10 percent of our electricity supplies come from new, clean renewable energy resources by 2020;
  • Cut taxpayer-funded handouts to dirty energy industries;
  • Decrease pollution to our air, land and water; and
  • Provide a reliable electricity system with adequate consumer protections that will save consumers money and increase energy efficiency.

This bill does not meet those minimum, basic standards. It takes us backward, not forward. The Senate energy bill is unacceptable in its current form. We call upon Senators to oppose further attempts to pollute this bill with amendments to drill in one of our last pristine wilderness areas, the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, increase dirty energy subsidies, or weaken environmental protections. Instead, a forward-thinking energy policy should advance America's energy security by curtailing our dependence on dirty and unreliable energy sources, tapping into our vast potential for clean renewable energy, and dramatically increasing energy efficiency.